My Friend Robin

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• bikernjeeks (138)
• [2004-12-15 16:21]

Excellent shot - very nice sharp details on the bird, pretty colours, good blurred background. Well done!

•  
• willie (2083)
• [2004-12-15 16:29]

Splendid shot Jean. Excellent Detail, colour and composition with nice blurred BG. Good job

•  
• Xplorator (7614)
• [2004-12-15 16:34]
• [+]

Looks very good on thumbnail but when enlarged the lack of sharpness its compelling

•  
• extramundi (12764)
• [2004-12-15 18:20]
• [+]

The backlight, composition and colours here are very nice. I dont like the work NI did this time. I am sure this shots worths a mask and PS advanced blur or/and filter instead. Jean M., I am very interested on looking at more shots with the Sony tele, hope to see soon.

•  
• marhowie (35277)
• [2004-12-15 19:57]

Jean Micheal, Good shot with good color seen. Although a this one lacks sharpness, it is well worth posting. I enjoyed reading your personalized notes. I've always fed the birds during winter also! TFS

•  
• pmende (0)
• [2004-12-15 20:38]

Lovely photo, I really like the highlights on the robin and leaves. This is a very simple and pleasing photo.

•  
• Janice (17794)
• [2004-12-15 20:57]

Jean Michel, this little Robin is cute. It is a great shot of him, and I love his colours, his feathers are so pretty. You write excellenbt notes. TFS, Janice

•  
• ellis49 (28939)
• [2004-12-16 1:06]

Very good Jean.
Great colours and details.But the BG it's not good.
This beautiful picture deserve a better PP, and do not use NI to sharp it, use USM instead.
Good note.
Very well done.

•  
• Callie (7501)
• [2004-12-16 1:31]

Hi Jean Micheal
Mustbe one of the best loved birdies in the world, and you got a very nice shot of him here!
The backlighting is superb and I just love the innocent look on his face.

•  
• Luc (14719)
• [2004-12-16 4:18]

Salut Jean-Michel!
Ah qu'il est joli, cet oiseau! Mignon comme tout!
Nous n'avns pas cette espèce au Québec.
Notre merle est plus 'rugueux'.
Une excellente présentation: image et note.
Merci

•  
• red45 (26975)
• [2004-12-16 4:58]
• - [workshop] [compare]

So cute bird! Excellent colours and pose. Good composition. Too much noise, unfortunatelly. Look at my workshop - I removed some.

•  
• RAP (7405)
• [2004-12-16 6:02]

Composition: ****
Sharpness: ***
Color: ****
DOF: ****
POV: ****
Note: ***

Gran imagen Jean Michel ... sólo remarcaría el foco algo soft y algo de exceso en filtrado de NI.

Great image Jean Michel... only I would remark the focus little soft and something of filtrate excess of NI.

•  
• netfalls (0)
• [2004-12-16 6:58]

Composition: ****
Sharpness: ****
Color: ****
DOF: ***
POV: ****
Note: ****

Beaucoup de bruit sur cette photo, l'oiseau aurait besoin d'un peut plus de place a l'avant.
Tres bon BG.
TFS.

•  
• Lourens (1130)
• [2004-12-16 9:02]

Nice shot, Jean. Very nice composition.

•  
• coasties (27526)
• [2004-12-17 4:44]

Hi Jean Michel

Nice composition. The detail of the Robin is wonderful. I like the pose, best foot forward! Great note.TFS

•  
• japie (5187)
• [2004-12-17 10:05]

This is a beautiful composition, but as the guys have mentioned, a bit soft. A fill flash would have addedlifted more detail.

I still like the shot a lot.

Well done and thanks for posting.

•  
• Signal-Womb (10986)
• [2004-12-18 15:29]

Another excellent Robin shot on TN. Love the pose and the play of light on this one. Well done.

•  
• bartove (5381)
• [2005-01-04 16:48]

Excellent photo,the highlights on the robin is very nice. Very well done.

•  
• radz (3390)
• [2005-01-06 23:34]

Good light,POV&DOF.I know how tough to get them pose,you got with fine details.Beautiful shot.

•  
• livios (16856)
• [2005-01-31 13:36]
• [+]

Jean Michel, the bird is very cute and lovely. DOF is perfect, as well as composition. As for the noise, according to what Felipe said, maybe a blurred BG would be a better solution. What do you think of that?

•  
• liquidsunshine (11488)
• [2005-02-03 14:17]

This is a nice shot Jean,
I love taking photos of Robins, they are so friendly.
Good detail.
Thanks for posting

•  
• cloverstar (0)
• [2005-02-18 5:43]
• - [workshop] [compare] [+]

Very nice close up of this robin. The depth of field is excellent.
I did a workshop to try to remove some of the noise from the background with the blur tool, instead of the usual NeatImage method. I hope you like it.

•  
• mishe (661)
• [2005-07-22 16:00]

Salut Jean!
Very beautiful friend and photo.TFS.
Best wishes and regards from Makedoniya,
Mihajlo.