Coot Feed

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• Signal-Womb (10933)
• [2005-08-04 19:51]
• - [workshop] [compare] [+]

Hello Paul, very good low POV on this lovely capture. I think I would increase levels and the colour saturation on this just to enhance the green and brighten up the image with a little more colour. I dont want to give this one point because compo and sharpness is v good. Iv posted WS 6/10 Well done.

•  
• Fisher (8915)
• [2005-08-04 21:16]

Hi Paul,
Excellent POV and well done on this capture.
Your lighting is well controlled and the colors are fine.
With respect to Emerson, I see no difference between this and w.s.
TFS and well presented,[note]

Mike

•  
• jossim (11878)
• [2005-08-04 22:53]

Superbe prise nature, l'action du petit faché le bec ouvert en fait une belle composition.

La lumière et la netteté des sujets sont parfaits.

•  
• CaptiveLight (1129)
• [2005-08-05 1:00]

Nice well timed image, colours and the detail of the pond weed really help to make this.

•  
• softflower (0)
• [2005-08-05 2:45]

Very nice capture Paul with this 2 birds.
Very good POV and colours.
TFS.
Nico.

•  
• red45 (26857)
• [2005-08-05 4:29]

Hi Paul!
Nice scene. I like coots much more than ducks ;-) Hard to capture with all this blacks and whites together but you did it well. Great eyes - red on black and black on gray ;-)

•  
• dew77 (13069)
• [2005-08-05 4:39]

Hello Paul!
Very nice and cute scane.Expression on the faces,clear details are wonderful.Limited DOF and lighting raised the value of composition.
In my opinion(may be it was not possible)it would be better if you caught this scane at a little righter side.TFS...:-)

•  
• coasties (27512)
• [2005-08-05 7:44]

Hello Paul

Nice low POV. Very good exposure and timing. A great moment captured. Well done and thanks.

•  
• marhowie (34537)
• [2005-08-05 8:27]

Great capture Paul! Very good exposure, sharpness, DOF and details. The POV and interplay between the two is tremendous IMHO. Well done..

•  
• AndyB (3978)
• [2005-08-05 12:15]
• [+]

A very nice shot Paul.
I really like the low POV here.
You've handled the exposure very well indeed and the lighting is great.
Good sharp detail of both birds and very good composition.
Nice work,have a great weekend....the forecast looks a little better :-))

•  
• thistle (9152)
• [2005-08-05 14:30]
• [+]

Great capture Paul!
The POV couldn't have been better, lighting and details are very good as well.
I like the composition. If it was centered the left part of the photo would've been "heavier" than the right - I think this space on the right helps well to balance the photo.
Overall, very interesting post.
WELL DONE & TFS

•  
• chiliu (6442)
• [2005-08-05 17:10]

Hi Paul,
I missed this one!
This is a brilliant picture of the Wildnature!
I really like the scene, and depth of field, and POV, and composition.
SUPERB!
TFS!
Chi

•  
• scottevers7 (12257)
• [2005-08-05 23:26]

Hi Paul,
A very good shot of this adult and young Coot. Color,detail, and DOF are spot on in this one. Nice Shot!
Scott

•  
• nixpix (426)
• [2005-08-06 1:01]

Cool shot PDP. Interesting with the chic begging food from its mother. I would have chopped some off on the right, bottom and top to get into the subject a little more. Regards, Rob

•  
• deud (2121)
• [2005-08-06 3:05]

very nice pov and amazing dof! the green algeas are great decorative elements in image. very well exposed. good work.

•  
• livios (16856)
• [2005-08-06 12:25]

Paul, this is indeed a great moment, but what I like the most about this shot is sharpness. To me, it's perfect.

Great pov, great composition.

A lovely scene.

•  
• dsidwell (680)
• [2005-08-06 20:31]

The thumbnail doesn't do this justice, Paul. I love the unique point of view here, and the small dispute that seems to be taking place is very engaging.

•  
• sAner (4742)
• [2005-08-08 14:30]
• [+]

Hi Paul,

The scene is great and the low POV is fantastic. I like the composition. On my monitor the left part and a part of the tail of the adult coot are way too dark. Is it my monitor? DOF is excellent aswell. TFS!

Regards,
Pieter

•  
• Luc (14713)
• [2005-08-09 1:31]

Sorry, I have no time to comment today. But I give you the well deserved smily.