Salvaging Ohio for Ron Warner

Critiques [Translate]

•      
• cataclysta (4772)
• [2008-09-10 8:25]
• [+]

Hi Bob
Beautiful autumn - winter compilation. All the shots are great. First of all interesting moment - transition between two seasons. I like also the mood on your shots and great orange and red vs white and grey.
TFS
Krzysztof

•      
• oanaotilia (635)
• [2008-09-10 8:37]

Hy Bob
I like your colage with mixture of snow, gold leaves, water. I miss this atmosphere, here in Belgium. It is a time to stay inside,near the fire, with a cup of boiled wine. Thanks a lot!
Oana

•  
• pankajbajpai (15175)
• [2008-09-10 8:52]

hello bob,
fine dedication, the one aspect i liked in these image is the colors of fall, they looks so beautiful, you have made a good compilation depciting the beauty of nature,
well done,
tfs & regards
pankaj

•  
• Crosman (44)
• [2008-09-10 10:17]
•  [Show CommentHide Comment]

•  
• nglen (22528)
• [2008-09-10 10:26]

Hi Bob. Your pictures today get us ready for winter which will not be to long . I love the colours of early winter with the reds and oranges. Each one is a good picture alone well set out. TFS interesting notes too.
Nick..

•  
• Seabird (1117)
• [2008-09-10 10:46]

Hi, Bob,

a great combination of your masterpieces!! very well presented and they are all great captures with poetic atmosphere.

just want to say Hi before I take a half-year break from TN. many thanks for the encouragement, pointers and insightful notes all along. i have had a great time at TN. But I guess it's time for me to stay focused on my study and the Final Exam, which is just less than 5 months away.

take care, my respected friend. I will certainly miss you and other photography mentors here.

chrs,
Man Yee

•  
• jaycee (16095)
• [2008-09-10 13:47]

Hi Bob,

A lovely collage reminding almost everyone of what is coming. Beautiful fall colors and the snow is pretty in pictures. This is a reminder for me of the changing seasons back east. I'm sure Ron will love this.

Jane

•  
• tuslaw (2358)
• [2008-09-10 14:31]

Thank you Bob,
I feel honored to have you dedicate such wonderful treasures of your past experiences to me. The images are a showcase of how beautiful the state of Ohio really is.
We have four seasons, and each one has it's own scenes, colors and smells that set it apart from the others. We have terrain which is as diverse as anywhere in the US., and then we have that magnificent Lake Erie to our north.
Thanks again for this outstanding collage and your very informative video.
Ron

•  
• jrobertop (660)
• [2008-09-10 16:04]

Hello Bob.
Congratulations for marvellous dedication!
The colage is super interesting, presenting its photographic art!
Very well done,in all aspects!
Cheers,
José Roberto

•  
• Luis52 (10447)
• [2008-09-10 17:25]

Hi Bob.-
So You also have an old lens eh? In my personal opinion they work better than the new ones, if You konw how to handle. Great work, lovely colors and excellent presentation.
Luis52.

•  
• Jamesp (15234)
• [2008-09-10 22:55]

Hi Bob

Really lovely collage - well constructed with well placed imaged. Colours and details are good in each.

James

•  
• Mana (17188)
• [2008-09-10 23:50]

Hi Bob,
Excellent collage of shots with beautiful colours and lovely settings. All the images look so atractive and lively. You really have captured the ambience and mood perfectly. Thanks for sharing this fine collage.
Sumon

•  
• ramthakur (26195)
• [2008-09-11 0:08]

This is a charming collage of pictures taken nearly 40 years ago, Bob, and how you retrieved them must be a story unto itself. I will go to your video later and react to your collage first.
All the pictures in the collage are of high quality. The fall colors are already there, but it is the well balanced contrasts in them that impress me the most. I particularly like the untimely snow on fall leaves in the first frame.
Your images from the past are dispensing a lot of joy to people like me, so thank you and keep them coming. . . .
Ram

•  
• JoseMiguel (5187)
• [2008-09-11 0:51]

Hi Bob,
As usual, a work with a lot of dedication and sensibility.
I like a lot the composition you made with the 5 images, talking only about the layout it is very good, and every single picture has the right size to be better appreciated.
The golden tones of the overall composition makes of this a very special work to see and enjoy.
Invaluable work and thanks for share it with us.
Warm regards,
JM

•  
• haraprasan (13336)
• [2008-09-11 2:02]

Namastay Bob,
A beautiful montage of this autumn-winter captures way back in 70s'. Very informative and useful video. Nice colors. Thanks a lot for sharing.

Sincerely
HP

•  
• horia (13149)
• [2008-09-11 3:23]
• [+]

Hi Bob

A gorgeous collage and a very nice presentation, my friend!
The presentation of the places there is lovely, the note is interesting and the video (finally got the time to watch it) is really helpful! I actually will think twice about some old family pics now :)

Back to this collage, the shots in its are all very nice and moody again. The show a splendid place is different stages and different angles, letting the viewer understand more about it.
Very nice work and contribution!

Bravo and TFS
Horia

•  
• lousat (11326)
• [2008-09-11 4:17]

It's a great work my friend,but we need subtitle in italian or french..eheheh...it's enough to see this beautifull puzzle to me,5 wonderfulls pics,thanks a lot for share and for the lesson too,have a nice day,Luciano

•  
• joey (22002)
• [2008-09-11 14:28]

Hello Bob,
a wonderful collage of photos.
I love the winteriness of it :-)
Each shot is sharp, well composed and very well exposed.
Great to see how you made this too... that's one hell of a cool scanner! :-)

Cheers,
Joe

•  
• gannu (11874)
• [2008-09-11 21:40]

WoW BOB what a shot. Superb and this is 70 and when I was 6 year sold and you preserve it. Superb Ganesh

•  
• Silvio2006 (26183)
• [2008-09-12 5:52]

Ciao Bob, fantastic collage of splendid nature composition with wonderful colors, great work, very well done, ciao Silvio

•  
• EOSF1 (23221)
• [2008-09-12 10:13]

Hello Bob! What can I say? Great job my friend, lots of great shots and a beautiful presentation ! You always put the bar a little higher! Well done my friend!

Mario

•  
• CeltickRanger (7691)
• [2008-09-12 14:16]

hello Bob

in my long absence of one month i missed alot of your
wonderful landscape shot, i decide to choose 2 of your image
to critique (to have smileys ton every one),

first i love very much this mid fall images photo-montage,
on the images i love the automnal colours and snow,
the one i love most is the 2 upper ones, and on the one
with the snow, i love the mix of the automnal colours with the snow,

TFS

Asbed

•  
• jpinkham (618)
• [2008-09-14 5:24]

How do I like this montage, Bob? Let me count the way :) First, I can see why that upper left photo is a prize -- with color and clarity and focus you've captured the clash of seasons...and how abrupt the shift can sometimes be. Second, you've shown those riparian scenes very well -- and I like the recurring use of river and color as a unifying element in these images. Third, an especially nice use of line in the lower image. Fourth, you've taken the time and effort to instruct us all.

Thanks, Bob!
Jim