Gatekeeper butterfly

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• carper (8410)
• [2004-07-29 13:32]
• - [workshop] [compare]

Very nicee one Andy,
I have just made a photo of this beautiful butterfly yesterday. Good composition, good dof. But with this photo can cropping do wonder. Very good job

•  
• Callie (7507)
• [2004-07-29 15:16]

Andy
That thingamegic on his nose, can you use it to brush of the clothes as you enter the gate? This ia a vert nice and clear picture, but I would have been nice to see some more space on the right for him to move into. Some of the open space on the left could be lost in cropping.

•  
• Esox (948)
• [2004-07-29 16:05]

Nice macro shot.
Good details and colors.
I agree with my friends on cropping, but however, it stay a success.
Well done.

•  
• Jax (490)
• [2004-07-29 17:10]

Nice shot, great detail and colour.

•  
• PDP (11765)
• [2004-07-29 17:23]
• - [workshop] [compare]

Nice work Andy, Fantastic detail and DoF. I did a workshop on it, not beacuse I thought it was bad but I wanted to see what is wat like with a tighter crop. Hope you like it.

Paul

•  
• japie (5187)
• [2004-07-30 3:41]

Very good detail and DOF, but I do agree with Callie on the crop. Points tomorow

•  
• jhm (626)
• [2004-07-30 13:24]

A very beautiful Butterfly, excellent of colours Andy.

•  
• Robbrown (6054)
• [2004-07-30 13:56]

Good image very niceley sharp a little lacking in DOF and a bit tight for space on the right made worse by the large amount of space on the left, but otherwise nice one same goes for the short note too.
looks like its points tommorrrow Ive now caught up.

•  
• mogens-j (20)
• [2004-07-30 18:00]

Nice and crispy picture Andy. Colours and dof are spot on as well as the light. But I would prefer the butterfly looking into the picture instead out of it - meaning more space in front than behind.

•  
• letr (130)
• [2004-08-06 11:02]

Great Macro with excellent details Andy..Good Job !!

•  
• livios (16888)
• [2005-03-26 8:59]
• - [workshop] [compare]

Andy, this shot is very nice. Excellent sharpness and colors.

I also tried a little workshop, in order to suggest a different composition.

•  
• malgosia (0)
• [2005-07-02 18:59]

hello Andy:)

great colours:)
exellent POV:)
exellent DOF:)

tfs:)

Malgosia

•      
• phlr (2804)
• [2005-07-12 11:55]

Great shot! 5*!
This species is also common in my country, Portugal.
It flys till later automm.