American Tree Sparrow

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• Luc (14709)
• [2005-02-08 20:41]

Critique:
Appréciation personnelle de la photo: excellente.
Bon impact visuel.
Pertinence de la photo pour le site: excellent. C'est le premier bruant hudsonien que je vois sur TN.
Appréciation personnelle pour la note: complète et bilingue.
Commentaire:
Salut René,
je l'aurais probablement rognée dans le bas jusqu'à former un carré. Ça aurait éliminé de l'information visuelle inutile, à mon sens. Pour le reste c'est un excellent boulot. La longeur de ses griffes centrales est impressionnante.
Je ne connais pas les conditions de température dans lesquelles tu naviguais ce jour-là, mais je crois que tu aurais pu utiliser une vitesse moindre pour augmenter le champ de profondeur.
Bravo et merci.

•  
• marhowie (34117)
• [2005-02-08 21:21]

Rens, Superb sharpness & detail here..Perfect light, nice pose & well composed..Very nice!!

•  
• sergegagne (401)
• [2005-02-08 22:35]

Excellente prestation, René. Tout est parfait à mon avis. Et hop! dans mes favoris! Merci pour vos contributions toujours... régalantes.

•  
• elroyie (6395)
• [2005-02-08 22:53]

Great quality, very good capture of this little one with very good composition.

•  
• coasties (27488)
• [2005-02-09 3:54]

Great sharpness and detail Rene. Such long claws. Excellent DoF. Nice work as always. TFS

•  
• AmiBe (68)
• [2005-02-09 4:23]

Il est très beau ce bruant ! J'aprécie la netteté sur l'oiseau, les couleurs ainsi qu'une DOF bien choisie.

•  
• sAner (4742)
• [2005-02-09 6:07]

Rzorsharp details, superb lightening, nice composition and presentation. Wonderful. Don't you just love these little sparrows? :) Some people think they're dull because of their rather dull colors, but I just love them. In NL we call this "mus".

•  
• gerhardt (11529)
• [2005-02-09 6:37]

Superb capture, Excellent composition and POV. Tack sharp. Great catch Rene.

•  
• PDP (11733)
• [2005-02-09 7:50]

Very nice work Rene, lovely looking sparrow and you have done him proud. The composition and background are great and I love browns and greys so the colurs are superb too.

Very well done.

•  
• livios (16848)
• [2005-02-09 10:08]

René, quite a lovely shot. Nice composition, shades, sharpness, DOF and POV. The background is okay too.

In short, another perfect one.

Lívio

•  
• extramundi (12676)
• [2005-02-09 10:50]

Excellent shots you have posted lately. I hate being away some time and not being able to recover time and critique all good shots. This one is very beautiful, superb clearness and colours. I dont think sparrows are as beautiful as you got here, you improved nature this time :)
The forest drummer is also impressing. Thanks.

•  
• puciu (2599)
• [2005-02-09 10:58]

Szkoda ¿e nie w kwdracie, ali i tak fajne zdjêcie.

•  
• ellis49 (28605)
• [2005-02-09 11:14]

Very nice shot René.
Great composition, POV, very good details and colours.
Excellent work.

•  
• Fisher (8915)
• [2005-02-09 12:14]

Rene, a very nice capture showing it's distinctive mark, the black spot on the breast. Well done with this composition and details.

Mike

•  
• willie (2083)
• [2005-02-09 12:38]

Stunning Rene. Brilliant work. No nits.

•  
• liquidsunshine (11474)
• [2005-02-09 12:56]

Excellent shot Rene,
great sharpness and detail. Very nice composition
Thanks for posting

•  
• Lesley (2988)
• [2005-02-09 13:58]

One of my very favorite Sparrows and we only see them in the cold winter here in Massachusetts. Very nice shot, Rene.

•  
• Signal-Womb (10755)
• [2005-02-09 14:10]

Excellent shot with great pose on the bird and nice detail revealed. The dof has a great effect here. Well done Rene.

•  
• LCannon (3004)
• [2005-02-13 16:17]

Very wonderful composition, the tree branches seem perfectly placed. The feathers are clear and sharp, the background nicely blurred. Excellent.