Members: alscha >> Critiques Written


Critiques: Critiques Written | Critiques Received | Comments
Page: 1 2  >

PhotoCritique [Translate]

alscha (134) [2006-11-06 12:27]

hi dotuan,
this is such a great shot!!!love the format, not quie sure about the yellow font, personally i would prefer a smaller font, not italic and grey or white. this is sooo fab!!
i definatly like this shot best of the series of typhoons that you have posted. i love the way you can get a sense of scale with the sea and the mountains in the background and the white line on the horizon.

alscha (134) [2006-10-25 16:31]

wow ahmet, this is amazing, so sharp, love the contrasts of the soft bird feathers, the rusty barbed wire, both in a similar tone and then the yellow wasp. great shot, tonal range and composition, depth of field and especially great because it shows the bird with its prey.

alscha (134) [2006-10-22 17:21]

Hi Jan Arie, the first though that crossed my mind was that this is a depticiton of Aslan, from C.S.Lewis' Chronicles of Narnia!
I love the lighting, the tonal range and the composition. If i had to critique something it would be to crop out some of the space on the left and have left some more space on the right, but i really do find it a really great image!!!

alscha (134) [2006-10-22 17:18]

Hi Karan,
I really liek the way you have approached this shot, the lighting, composition and the bw. great, thanks for sharing. alex

Title: purple
purple (36)
csmnlm Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Note Writer [C: 95 W: 0 N: 66] (449)


alscha (134) [2006-10-22 17:16]

hi cemil, amazing colours, contrast and details, love the p.o.v. and d.o.f. just great. thanks for sharing. alex

alscha (134) [2006-10-22 17:15]

Hi Barbara,
I really love this shot, silhouette and pattern and sunset/rise together! thanks for sharing

alscha (134) [2006-10-22 17:12]

Hi Mario,
I really like the way you have captured this duck in flight. really great shot, thanks for sharing

alscha (134) [2006-10-22 17:09]

Hi Pam, this is so sharp and lovely photo of a bird. i like the range of colours, and really nice how you composed it with the branch going out through corners of frame. really like it. thanks for sharing

Title: eagle
eagle (11)
Karin Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Note Writer [C: 418 W: 5 N: 268] (2089)


alscha (134) [2006-10-22 17:07]

hi karin, great shot of this eagle!!!like the and the colours, great expression! thanks for sharing

alscha (134) [2006-10-22 17:06]

very dreamy mood. nice shot. how did you do it, long shutter speed? thanks for sharing