Members: Clochette >> Critiques Written

Register

Critiques: Critiques Written | Critiques Received | Comments
Page: << <  1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8  >

PhotoCritique [Translate]

Clochette Gold Star Critiquer [C: 72 W: 6 N: 94] (342) [2005-07-10 5:38] [+]

There’s a long time I’ve been wishing to write this message to you.
In spite of the 40 critiques you have received, you only gave 1… to your own son !
In spite of all demands from other members, asking to you for larger posts, you go on posting small ones.
You rarely write notes with your posts, or very short and not informative ones.
It’s all the more a pity, that your pics seem to be good, but it’s difficult to make an opinion on so small formats.

As a summary, I would say I deeply regret that you do not play the game.
If everyone here had the same attitude, there would not be anymore exchanges on TN.

*********************************************

Ca fait longtemps que j’ai envie de vous laisser ce message.
Malgré les 40 critiques qui vous ont été attribuées, vous n’en avez donné qu’une seule en retour, et … à votre propre fils !
Malgré toutes les demandes qui vous ont été faites pour que vous publiez, comme les autres, de plus larges formats, vous ne répondez à personne et continuez à poster de mini-images.
Les notes accompagnant vos photos sont rares, et très succintes.
C’est d’autant plus dommage que vos clichés semblent bons, mais difficile d’en juger sur de si petits formats.

En bref, vous ne jouez pas le jeu et c’est regrettable.
Si chacun ici faisait comme vous, il n’y aurait bientôt plus aucun échange sur ce site.

Clochette Gold Star Critiquer [C: 72 W: 6 N: 94] (342) [2005-07-09 6:57]

Hi Paolo
Excellent ! A good control of exposure, light and DOF. Sharpness is perfect, with amazing details. Great work !!

France
Title: V
V (20)
Midi Gold Star Critiquer/Silver Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 146 W: 24 N: 183] (2418)

Great

Clochette Gold Star Critiquer [C: 72 W: 6 N: 94] (342) [2005-07-09 6:56]

Bonjour Jean-Louis
Il s'agit d'une Belle Dame (Vanessa Cardui pour le nom latin).
Excellente DOF qui permet une netteté impeccable du papillon sur toute sa longueur, par contre la lumière devait être forte (pas comme ici :-(((( et il aurait peut-être fallu sous-exposer un tout petit peu.

Clochette Gold Star Critiquer [C: 72 W: 6 N: 94] (342) [2005-07-09 6:50]

A beautiful, and somehow elegant composition. You are right, the uniform dark blue background is perfect for this subject. Also a perfect control of white areas. Excellent !

Clochette Gold Star Critiquer [C: 72 W: 6 N: 94] (342) [2005-07-09 6:47]

Hi Cem
I just discover your first shot for TN... What a start !!!
This is undoubtedly one of the most beautiful pic of gulls I ever saw. All is perfect, I miss words to express my admiration.
CONGRATULATIONS !!!

Poland
Title: insect 15
insect 15 (36)
puciu Gold Star Critiquer/Silver Note Writer [C: 469 W: 0 N: 16] (2631)

Great

Clochette Gold Star Critiquer [C: 72 W: 6 N: 94] (342) [2005-07-09 6:41]

Wow, that's a beauty !!!
Excellent focus of course, but also the colors make the pic. What a beautiful environment for your bee.. Wonderful composition, thank you !

Clochette Gold Star Critiquer [C: 72 W: 6 N: 94] (342) [2005-07-09 6:38]

Hi Heinz
Excellent DOF and focus on this beautiful insect. A little over exposure on the flower, which is not that disturbing.
Beautiful details, a great macro, thank you !

Clochette Gold Star Critiquer [C: 72 W: 6 N: 94] (342) [2005-07-09 6:35]

Hi Jaap
Very good focus on the head, and particularly on the eye. Colors are vivid and attractive.
Well done !

Clochette Gold Star Critiquer [C: 72 W: 6 N: 94] (342) [2005-07-08 8:32] [+]

Hi Julia !
A golden fly with green and red eyes, what a look ! ;-)
In my opinion it could have been slightly more sharpened, but anyway this is a great shot ! Thank you.

Clochette Gold Star Critiquer [C: 72 W: 6 N: 94] (342) [2005-07-08 8:28]

WOW !!!
What on earth could it be ?
Never, never saw this kind of dragonfly, perhaps it is not one, just like the Sulphur Ascalaphe I posted a few days ago.
Anyway, a very good pic Jagath, sharp, with a beautiful DOF. And this insect is definitely incredible !!!
Congratulations !