Robin (Erithacus rubecula)

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• wishnugaruda (19365)
• [2006-04-09 7:16]

Hallo Thorsten,
ach wie süüüß, dieses Rotkehlchen schaut sich um, wie ertappt!
Die Schärfe ist excellent, ebenso die Farben.
Du fütterst also auch noch, mir ist es leider nun ausgegangen, um nirgendwo kann man noch was kaufen - zu allem Übel haben die bösen Wettermelder schon wieder Schnee angedroht - ich mag nicht mehr!!!
Tschüssi
Sabine - wishnugaruda

•  
• dew77 (13270)
• [2006-04-09 7:32]

Hello Thorsten!
Excellent capture.I liked POV,clear details,simple BG,pose
of kızılgerdan;)(do you have Turkish keyboard?),framing,catchlight in eyes,framing and composition a lot.TFS...:-)

•  
• pvs (14464)
• [2006-04-09 7:49]

Hi Thorsten,

A very nice capture of the robin,yesterday I saw that the first one arrived here as well,but could not capture him yet,picture is very sharp and detailed and composition is very nice on the brownish BG,well done

Paul

•  
• Matt-Bird (1942)
• [2006-04-09 8:15]

Nice shot Thor. Nice and clear shot with a good POV. I like your notes.
Matt

•  
• Zeno (10867)
• [2006-04-09 8:23]

Hi Thorsten,

Nice, satured colours in this robin. I also like the pose of the bird and the background.

TFS.
Zeno.

•  
• wuta (2142)
• [2006-04-09 8:55]

Hello Thorsten I'ts a beauty bird , nice pose colours pov
dof and framing ,very good ,tfs Greeting Teunie .

•  
• larevedere (123)
• [2006-04-09 10:29]

Hi Thorsten...
I meet you again... last time it was on TE :))
But here you have very good photos, too.
This one is very nice :)
Regards,
Olaf

•  
• jchemas (3396)
• [2006-04-09 10:38]

What an incredible shot of this robin Thorsten.
The colors and the details are superb.
Great POV and BG and love the framing.
TFS!!!!
Regards
JC

•  
• wallhalla15 (13829)
• [2006-04-09 10:39]

Hallo Thorsten,
excellentes Foto vom Rotkehlchen. Sehr gute Bildgestaltung, natürliche Farben und tadellose Schärfe. I wünsche Dir noch einen schönen Restsonntag.
Gruß
Heinz

•  
• ramthakur (56953)
• [2006-04-09 11:01]

Sehr schönes Bild, Thorsten.
The picture is perfect in every respect.
The idea of using a nut-stick is great, as I notice many of you good photographers using it frequently. I have birds in my compound but they are allergic to my presence even 50 meters away! Maybe I should use the same ploy.
Sorry for trying my rusty Deutsch on you.
Ram

•  
• mogens-j (20)
• [2006-04-09 11:41]

Excellent capture of this little beauty Thorsten. Great sharpness and lots of details in the bird. The colours are very good and look very natural. perfect handling of the light. The background is well blurred. Very good composition and I really like the pose and pov. Great job you did here.

•  
• aido (4046)
• [2006-04-09 12:19]

Hi Thor,
A great shot, perfect detail and colour, composition is good and background is perfectly defocused. Great work.
Cheers,
Adrian

•  
• elefantino (14406)
• [2006-04-09 13:17]

Hi Thor, well done, again.
Super-sharp and colorful shot.
Thanks.
Andrea

•  
• red45 (31094)
• [2006-04-09 13:24]

Hi Thor!
Very nice shot of this Rudzik ;-) I like its pose and composition.

•  
• Aramok (5166)
• [2006-04-09 15:57]

lovely picture of a robin. they are amongst my favourite birds. whenever I go to work on our track, I always take my camera withme, becuase once we get worksing, there will alwya be one watching us and that is the ideal chance to capture it.

Also their song is wonderful, full of life and chatter.

I think the detail is your picture is great - liek you said it was missing from mine - and yours all show how it can be sone much better.
I also like the fact taht you are not afraid to include the bird feeding station - so people don't like them in the photos, but they are apart of our gardens and needed for a lot of birds.

TFS

•  
• livios (16942)
• [2006-04-09 18:51]

Thorsten, this is really very nice.

I like composition, colors and sharpness.

Lovely pov and catchlight.

A very nice image.

•  
• coasties (28054)
• [2006-04-09 20:19]

Hi Thorsten

A perfect shot that is well composed, with good clarity, depth of colour and sharpness. Detail is spot on. A big tick for this shot! :-)

•  
• osse (7805)
• [2006-04-10 6:53]

Hi Thorsten
Very sharp and detaild,shot.Good colour, composition, background and note.
Well done

osse

•  
• EOSF1 (23955)
• [2006-04-10 20:08]

Very nice Robin picture Thorsten, very good light, well exposed, great composition and very sharp. Thanks.

Mario

•  
• hummingbird24 (64)
• [2006-04-10 22:26]

Hello Thorsten,

A wonderful shot of this great looking robin, with lovely colors, exposure, pov, and details.

Well done and thank you!

•  
• marhowie (486)
• [2006-04-11 12:14]

Hi Thorsten,
Well framed with excellent color, exposure, POV, DOF and sharp details..Nice OOF BG also.
9/10... (-1 for the feeder net) ;)
Well done!

•  
• cecilia (4630)
• [2006-04-11 18:56]

Very nice, I like the composition and the robins detail and colours are awesome...Excellent shot...

•  
• SkyF (8073)
• [2006-04-12 14:36]

Hallo Thorsten,
Putzig der kleine Kerl, hier sind die Rotkelchen viel groesser. Wunderschoen hast du ihn eingefangen die Farben und die Schaerfe ist prima.
Gruss..Sky

•  
• lestef (493)
• [2006-04-14 0:36]

Nice colours and details.
It seems like he is posing for you.
Springtime is back !

Stefan

•  
• dB_grafix (3019)
• [2006-04-15 6:08]

I sure like the clarity and detail in feathers.I am always impressed with such a good DOF as this is.The way you cropped with the tree as the frame is a good feature.

•  
• mjunge (32)
• [2006-04-15 13:23]

Hallo Thorsten,

tolles Foto, Du bist ja ein echter Vogelexperte wie ich sehe. Sehr scharf.

Gruß

Markus

•  
• Signal-Womb (11094)
• [2006-04-15 18:12]

Great capture Thorsten, I cant resist a good Robin shot. Very nice composition and lovely details revealed in the pens. Very well done.

•  
• TPAKT (89)
• [2006-04-16 11:47]

Privet Thorsten.
Good shot - precise, qualitative and interesting. Detailed elaboration is very good.

•  
• janhendrik (2392)
• [2006-05-30 14:48]

Guten abend Thorsten,

I really like this picture. It is crisp and sharp and I like the composition. Very well done.

Jan-Hendrik

•  
• dantor (993)
• [2006-05-31 18:37]

Hi Thorsten,
This must be your most popular photo and it's easy to see why: sharp image without being oversharpened, natural colours, perfect exposure, pleasing background, outstanding detail in the plumage and nice pose. Well done!

•  
• Pictures_Collec (509)
• [2006-06-11 15:27]

Great shot... Nothing more to say. Good job :-)
Thanks for the information.

•  
• snowfalken (1788)
• [2006-06-18 17:07]

Hallo Thorsten,

Sehr schoenes Foto! Ich denke das Licht war viel besser als in meinem Foto! Das Bild ist sehr scharf und die Farben wirken sehr natuerlich! Komposition ist auch sehr gut! Ich hoffe auch auf eine Gelegenheit das Rotkaehlchen im vollen Licht Fotografieren zu koennen! Danke!

Schoene Gruesse,
Eddie

•  
• pilonm (3321)
• [2006-06-21 6:55]

Hello Thor, Looking at your nice picture, I understand now why we call it in french "Rouge-Gorge" (translated literally by "red throat" in englih). And I see also from where our American Robin got his name. It is the first time I see the original from the old continent! Your picture is delightful with excellent pov and composition. The blurred bg enhanced very well the bird. And I always like the little sparkle in the eye! Great picture and TFS,

Michel

•  
• Adam73 (2253)
• [2006-07-21 0:58]

awesome colors, contrast, compostion, exposure, and sharpness. I love your pictures. Very awesome.

•  
• blakitan (5517)
• [2006-07-25 6:36]

Hi Thor,
Look like this is your 'home'. Very nice collection of your photos here. I guess this is the one that I love most. Great shot, Thor.

Ben Lakitan

•  
• Lynette (16)
• [2006-08-14 12:18]

Hello Thorsten, great dof, perfect pov and the note is excellent.
Full smileys to you!!!
: ) lynette

•  
• kirych (76)
• [2006-09-09 10:05]

Hi, Thorsten!
Beautifl bird and excellent composition! Wonderful DOF, colors, light and contrast frame. Good work! Tanya.

•  
• emka (41)
• [2007-12-04 13:46]

Hallo Thorsten,

fantastic shot of this little bird. I always wonder how it is possible to do such a photo.

I like it very much. Thank you
Malgorzata